How to Decide on a Product Idea for Your Etsy Shop (Hint Keep It Simple!)

So, you’ve decided to open an Etsy shop—yay! You’ve got the creative itch, the excitement is building, but then comes the big question: What on earth am I going to sell? Suddenly, all those ideas in your head go poof, and you’re left staring at a blank page. Sound familiar?

Don’t worry! You don’t need to reinvent the wheel to have a successful Etsy shop. In fact, some of the easiest products to create (and sell!) are digital products like planners, printables, and wall art. These gems are perfect if you’re looking to keep things simple, creative, and totally manageable—plus, they’re always in demand. Let’s dive into how you can choose the right digital product idea and start selling ASAP!

Step 1: Start with What You Enjoy

First things first: if you’re going to create something, make sure you actually enjoy making it. Think about what gets you excited or what you love working on. Are you obsessed with organization? (Planners might be your new BFF.) Do you love graphic design and typography? (Hello, wall art!) Or maybe you’ve always been the go-to person for designing invitations or party decor. Your hobbies and interests are a great starting point for picking a digital product.

Example Ideas:

  • If you’re the type who loves making lists, try creating a simple planner or to-do list template.
  • If you’re more visual, consider designing printables—things like motivational quotes, holiday-themed art, or even cute coloring pages.
  • Feeling crafty? How about creating party printables—invites, banners, and even matching place cards!

Step 2: Keep It Simple (Really, Simple Is Good!)

When you're starting out, it’s easy to overthink things and feel like your product needs to be elaborate or totally unique. Newsflash: it doesn’t! The beauty of digital products is that they can be super simple and still incredibly valuable to your customers. The goal is to create something that solves a problem or brings joy to people’s lives.

A simple planner template can help someone get organized. A printable wall art piece can brighten up a room. Sometimes the best products are the ones that make life a little easier or more beautiful—and they don’t need to be complicated to do that.

Pro Tip: Don’t try to create something for everyone. Narrow down your audience and focus on what they might need or want. For example, a minimalist meal planner for busy parents or a colorful, motivational quote for college dorm rooms.

Step 3: Use Tools You Already Know (or Can Learn Quickly!)

You don’t need a degree in graphic design to create digital products. If you’ve got basic computer skills and a little creativity, you’re golden! There are plenty of free and low-cost tools out there that make creating digital products a breeze.

  • Canva: Canva is a lifesaver. It’s free, easy to use, and has tons of templates for everything from planners to wall art. You can simply tweak a template to fit your style, and voila! You’ve got a product ready to go.
  • Google Docs or PowerPoint: Believe it or not, you can create awesome planners and printables using everyday tools like Google Docs or PowerPoint. Just set up your page with a grid or simple design, and export it as a PDF. Done and done!
  • Etsy: If you want to jazz up your designs with cute fonts or graphics, head over to Etsy. You can buy affordable, ready-to-use design elements that will make your products pop. Do check the user licence on each product, or you can shop at my Etsy shop where everything can be used for creating digital products to sell

Step 4: Test the Waters with Freebies (but Not Forever!)

If you’re nervous about whether your product will sell, try offering a free version first. This could be a simple printable or a one-page planner sheet. Not only will it help you gauge interest, but it’s also a great way to build an email list of potential buyers. Once people see how awesome your freebie is, they’ll be more likely to purchase your full product range.

But, quick reminder: don’t get stuck in freebie mode forever! It’s great for testing, but your main goal is to sell.

Step 5: Don’t Overthink It—Just Start!

The biggest obstacle to getting your Etsy shop going is overthinking. You might be worrying about whether your idea is good enough, or whether people will actually buy it. Here’s the secret: you won’t know until you try! And guess what? It doesn’t have to be perfect. Etsy is a place where creativity thrives, and people appreciate handmade, unique items, even if they’re not 100% flawless.

Start with one simple idea, create it, and list it in your shop. You can always tweak or add more products later. The important thing is to get started and keep the momentum going.

Final Thoughts: Keep It Fun!

At the end of the day, running an Etsy shop should be something you enjoy. Choosing a simple, easy-to-create digital product like planners, printables, or wall art is a fantastic way to dive into the Etsy world without getting overwhelmed. Plus, once you create your first product, you can sell it over and over again without having to remake it (hello, passive income!).

So, pick something you love, keep it simple, and just go for it! You’ve got this.

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link!